Ten reasons not to have a swimming pool

Like so many Brits who move to France (I count the SF, who is Swedish, as an honorary Brit), a swimming pool was on our list of must-haves. Having lived with one for 14 years, it will be on our list of must-not-haves if we ever move house. Why? Read on.

1.      The season is short

Like everyone else, we thought we would be swimming from March till October. Actually, it’s May to September, if you’re lucky. Some years, we have not swum until late June. Even if it’s heated (ours isn’t), you extend the season by only a few weeks, since the weather has to be good enough to want to swim.

2.      They require a lot of work

For what you get out, you have to put a lot in. You have to open it up in the spring, evict the winter residents (frogs and toads), spring clean it, keep it clean throughout the summer and constantly test the pH and chlorine levels. Then you have to prepare it for winter and cover it with an incredibly heavy cover designed to take an adult’s weight.

At this time of year, you spend two hours cleaning it so that it’s immaculate. Then the wind gets up and blows in all the string-like flowers and leaves from the oak tree strategically positioned upwind. This is how it looked this afternoon, after the gale that has been blowing for two days.

3.      They are expensive

I’m not talking about installing them, although of course you can kiss goodbye to at least 30,000€ to build one from scratch. No, just running one is costly. Ours is the old chlorine variety, which requires regular dosing not only with chlorine but also with other chemicals to keep the pH balance etc right. These ‘produits’ do not come cheap.

The pool requires various accessories, all with a short life. These include: vacuum cleaner and hose, summer cover to keep the warmth in overnight and which normally lasts only 3-4 seasons, nets for fishing out leaves and insects and all the technical stuff to keep the pump and filtration system in working order.

Keeping the pump turning over uses electricity, which is getting more costly, like everything else. If you try to economise by cutting down the number of hours it runs, you start getting problems with mould (see below).

Then there was the occasion when the SF wanted to lower the water level but forgot about it and emptied out ¾ of the water. It had to be almost entirely refilled, which was painfully apparent on our water bill that year. Not a friendly act either for the environment or the pocket.

Just a few of the chemicals required

4.      You get taxed on them

If you have a swimming pool, you have to pay local taxes on it: not only the taxes foncières (property tax) but also the taxe d’habitation (living tax). The latter reflects the rental value of the property, which is, of course, enhanced if there is a swimming pool.

The swimming pool cost is not disaggregated on the tax bills themselves so I’m not sure how much it adds up to. However, no doubt we could find out from the Impôts.

5.      You have to keep them secure

Several years ago, the French government passed a law requiring pool owners to secure them against people drowning in them. This meant installing at least one of the following: fencing of a regulation height with a special child-proof gate; a movement-sensitive alarm; a rigid retractable cover; or a hideous greenhouse-like structure, part of which you can slide back if you want to see the sky.

The penalty for failing to comply? 45,000€.

Naturally, all these things are expensive and the manufacturers were rubbing their hands. We chose the cheapest possible option, an alarm, and that set us back 250€.

Someone told us that the law has been repealed or modified but I have yet to find out if this is true.

6.      They get mould

For the past few years, we have had terrible problems with intractable mould. No matter how much we clean the pool or dose it with algicide, it still reappears. It might be that our liner is so old that its surface is roughened and gives the mould purchase to establish itself. Someone at the pool supplies shop also told us that the mould is becoming increasingly resistant to treatment. Since a new liner costs upwards of 2,500€, we will wait until ours has definitively given up before adopting that as a solution.

7.      They spring leaks

The rubber liner has a certain life – normally about 10 years. Ours is already living on borrowed time and we’re lucky that it has not yet started to crack. That is one of the commonest causes of leaks.

Another source of leaks, which can be even trickier to deal with, is the underground pipes. If one of those gets fractured because of the cold, it can involve digging up the garden to find the offending pipe. We had a persistent leak one year, but managed to find it fairly quickly, since it was under the paving beside the pool. Had it been elsewhere, it would have been more difficult to resolve.    

8.      Animals fall in

During our 14 years here, we have had the following in the pool: several dogs, a sheep, a calf (which drowned, alas), hedgehogs, lizards, frogs, toads, worms, spiders and various other insects.

Some friends had a pregnant cow fall in theirs one winter, which had to be hoisted out with a crane. The vet turned up and told them to prepare a bucket of coffee, which did the trick in reviving the cow and the calf was later born unharmed. Unfortunately, the distraught cow destroyed our friends’ liner in its attempts to climb out.

9.      Squadrons of wasps terrorise the hapless swimmers

In the heat and drought of summer, our pool is the only watering hole for some distance around. We put out water for the animals and birds, but the wasps prefer drinking from the pool. A variety of wasp with long legs can float on the water surface while drinking. You can’t always see them while swimming, which has resulted in several stings for our guests and us.

10. Pool-less friends and neighbours get the benefit without the work

Summer is when you find out how popular you are. Children from neighbouring maisons secondaires without pools turn up regularly to swim. We normally swim naked, since we are not overlooked, but you can put money on the kids turning up when you are in the pool. People whom you barely knew in England suddenly discover a burning desire to see you, since your swimming pool is excellent entertainment for their unruly children.

We have considered filling the pool in or even turning it into a gigantic fosse septique (septic tank). However, if we sold the house, this would make it less appealing to those unsuspecting Brits for whom a swimming pool is a must-have.

Copyright © 2011 A writer’s lot in France, all rights reserved


  1. Thanks for honest words , it made me think twice about our house search in Carrcasone , I did know they where trouble but still might go for a house with a pool . Andy /Anne Marie.8

    Liked by 1 person

    • Well, don’t let me put you off if you’d like a swimming pool. None of these problems is insuperable. In fact, we managed to overcome the mould problem a while ago. It’s good to have a pool when it’s hot in the summer, but bear in mind they are unused for a good 7 months a year, unless you heat them. Good luck!


  2. An interesting read thank you, particularly as we are near completing our purchase in France. Building a new pool and pool house/eating area is very much part of our plans. Early days in terms of research but we are thinking of a salt water pool at this stage. Would be interested in any thoughts/comments from those more experienced.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks for leaving a comment, Mark. You might notice that I wrote this post some years ago. Fortunately, since then we have solved the mould problem, although some of the other inconveniences remain. I have no experience of salt pools, so can’t help you there. You might try joining a forum on one of the many expat websites and asking about people’s experiences there. In the meantime, you may also want to consider a heat pump, or similar, to heat the pool. We don’t have a heated pool and, given that the spring down here in SW France has been very gloomy in recent years, the swimming season is often only June to mid-Sept. A pool is quite an investment, so you want to get the most out of it. Again, though, it would be wise to ask those who heat their pools. Bon courage!


  3. Jonathan, Will commented over a year ago, and so I am not sure if he will come back and find your comment. I will try to contact him and put you in touch, if you would find that helpful.


  4. In an attempt to ameliorate many of the ills you describe, we are on the verge of building a natural swimming pond in SW France. No chemicals, little electricity, and an attractive plant-filled pond to look at which fits the landscape, rather than a caribbean-coloured square in summer or a mucky cover in winter. I don’t imagine it will be maintenance-free, but it will be work for a gardener rather than a chemical engineer. As to whether it’s classed as a swimming pool or an agricultural pond: well, in our commune that seems to be a grey area. If we can get away with the latter, there will be no taxes to pay, and we’ll be able to use our own commmon sense approach to keeping it secure for children, rather than having to abide by inflexible regulations.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Several people near us have gone down that route and seem to be satisfied. It’s a bit late for us now that we’ve got a conventional pool. However, since I wrote the post, which is now a number of years ago, we’ve sorted out the algae problem and bought a robot that cleans the pool, thus saving us many hours of work. No one has ever come to inspect our security arrangements, but we keep the alarm in just in case. Good luck with yours.


    • Hi Will, can you advise who helped you do that, also SW France and considering the same, that’s to say assuming you built it?


  5. Interesting reading. We had a pool in the UK for about 12 years or so and it was little trouble really and a lot less effort than the lawn that was there previously.

    Now in the Lot et Garonne and it is only marginally more effort looking after the pool than in the UK and that is only because the warmer temperature takes the chlorine out a bit faster.

    Yes they do cost a bit to run but so does everything these days. We spend considerably less on the pool than our two children spend on their phones and have you seen how much people spend on a bicycle?

    Last time we worked it out the pool cost a little less to run for a month than one day out with a couple of kids.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you for commenting. As you’ll have gathered, some of my post was a bit tongue in cheek but some of it was serious. Since I wrote it – several years ago now – we have managed to master the persistent algae, although other people we know still struggle with it in theirs. Although the pool came into its own during the recent canicule, I still maintain that we would probably not have one again if we moved house. But it depends what your priorities are. I commiserate with you for your children’s spending on phones!


  6. I can really relate to the work required to maintain a pool, hubby is always moaning. I dont think alot of people realise how much work is involved and how important it is to keep the ph balance correct.

    I live in Portugal and have been swimming from April 1st this year and will probably swim until the night temperatures drop in November.

    I swim everyday and would not be without my pool 🙂 Not sure about skinny dipping thoug – may scare off the neighbours 🙂



    • Hi Piglet, Lucky you being able to swim from 1st April to November – much longer than us. We don’t have close neighbours, hence being able to swim in the nude.

      P.S. Are you any relation of Piglet in France who blogs about French life?


  7. All too true…(sigh). Last summer we had a warty toad the size of a football that took up residence in the corner of the pool, and no matter how often we moved him on, he returned, with an increasing sense of entitlement.


    • Our toads always drown, alas, or possibly they have succumbed to the cocktail of chemicals we have to use (which makes me wonder what they must do to us). We are often finding bloated bodies at the bottom (toads, that is, not people).


  8. My local town, Gramat, has an excellent municipal pool. Unfortunately the season is only three months (we are trying to get them to stay open in September which is a lovely month for swimming), but it’s big and wonderful for swimming laps during specified lunch and evening hours. The season fee is very reasonable.


    • We also have a very good pool at Villefranche, but it’s 25km away. Other outdoor municipal pools that are closer have a very short season, like yours.


  9. I say continue to swim in the nude when unexpected guests turn up and they must swim nude too if they wish to get in the pool. I once had my mother along at the house of a friend where the custom was to swim nude. Mom insisted on wearing a suit, but said it was not modesty but pride that kept her from baring herself.


    • It’s not a bad idea to force guests to do it too. However, I’m with your mother all the way when it comes to swimming nude in front of people I don’t know.


  10. An excellent post, Vanessa. All very true. However, we love swimming so much that it’s worth all the work and expense – just! We have had lizards, frogs and worms in our pool so far. I do hope we don’t get anything larger and four-legged in it. It must have been very upsetting to find the poor calf.
    We skinny dip too whenever we can, and we’ve had the odd shock when suddenly a vehicle rattles down the drive …


    • I forgot the snakes as well. It was awful finding the calf, which had fallen through the winter cover. One particular farmer’s cows are always getting out and they still do, despite this.

      We have found the pool a boon in very hot weather but still wonder if it’s worth the effort and expense.


I'd love to know your thoughts. Please leave a comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.